Wednesday, June 18, 2014

Comparing Water Samples from the Albany Pine Bush to Average Water Contaminants

Comparing Water Samples from the Albany Pine Bush to Maximum Water Contaminants

Intro:


Using the same method as my soil blog, I am comparing the data sets I collected on water to EPA standards found in a table. Because I could not find average water contaminants I will be comparing the water to the maximum set standards instead. Below are the tables: one is on aquatic life standards and the other on drinking water. The water samples collected came from natural wells within the Albany Pine Bush.

On a side note: the charts does not list Sb, but I looked it up and drinking water should be at .006 ppm and naturally there can be up to 5 ppm. I also found the Cr can be as high as 20 ppm in rivers, but most often around 5 ppm. Ba can actually be as high as 2 ppm in drinking water. Lastly, I could not find a set standard for Pb, but it appears the EPA is pushing for 0 ppm as a goal.

On another note: ND appearing in a box means the data is inconclusive, but most likely the trace elements are low.




Source:

http://www.water.ncsu.edu/watershedss/info/hmetals.html (tables)
www.epa.gov (info on elements)
http://www.lenntech.com/index.htm (info on elements)

Data:


Sample 1
  • by shrubs
  • near houses

Referring to both charts we can see that the natural well water is high in Sb and Cr for both drinking an naturally occurring concentrations. Cr is fine in aquatic standards though.

Sample 2
  • by shrubs and woods
  • recent control fire
  • not as close as 1 to urban development

I could not find anything on Cl, but I am going to assume it is high. Sb is as well high.

Sample 3
  • wooded area
  • recent control fire
  • near highway
  • note: water was vey cloudy

CR and Ba levels are to high for drinking water. Both seem fine to be in water for aquatic life.

Sample 4
  • same as sample 3

Cr is above drinking water standards. Although it would pass standards for aquatic life.

Sample 5
  • low shrubs
  • very close to landfill
Cr and Sb levels are above drinking standards. Sb is also above aquatic life standards.

Sample 6
  • low shrubs
  • very close to landfill
  • also near wetlands

Cr are to high for drinking standards, but not aquatic life standards. Ba most likely is fine for aquatic life standards. Pb is most likely a problem for drinking standards.

Sample 7
  • same as sample 6


Sb is too high for both standards. Ba is at maximum level for being acceptable in drinking water. Cr is acceptable only for aquatic life standards.

Sample 8
  • same as sample 6


Cr is too high for drinking levels, Sb is too high for everything.

Sample 9
  • closest sample to landfill

Cr is too high for drinking standards, but sine for aquatic life standards. Pb is most likely an issue for drinking standards.

Sample 10
  • in swamp area

Sb levels are high for both standards.

Sample 11
  • same as sample 10

Sb levels are high for both standards. Pb might also be an issue. Cr is too high only for drinking standards.

Sample 12
  • near parking lot of Albany Pine Bush Center














Sb is an issue for both standards. Cr is high only for drinking water.

Conclusions:

It appears that antimony is a serious issue for the Albany Pine Bush. As well, it looks like lead might be an issue. I will in a future study compare the water to the soil to see if there is a correlation.


Tuesday, June 17, 2014

Comparing Soil Samples from the Albany Pine Bush to Average Soil Contaminants

Comparing Soil Samples from the Albany Pine Bush to Average Soil Contaminants
Intro:

A & L Great Lakes Laboratory created a table from the USEPA Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response on the average contaminants you would expect to find in natural soils. Using the soil collected from the Albany Pine Bush I will compare heavy metal contaminants to averages found in the table. This will give me an idea of the levels found throughout the Pine Bush. If any samples seem to be very high in a certain contaminant I can then compare it to regulated standards.

Also note that I ran several tests on each sample. If there was not much variation then I only posted one data set. However, If there was variation among the two sets I posted both. Because soil is not consistent in mineral composition it is no surprise to see a range of values.

Source:
http://www.algreatlakes.com/PDF/factsheets/ALGLFS25_Metal_Concentrations_in_Natural_Soils.pdf


Data:

Sample 1
  • by shrubs
  • near houses

Looking at the table I can see that all of my values fall within the range except for antimony. This should be a little concerning seeing as antimony has high health risks. Cl is above the average.

Sample 2
  • by shrubs and woods
  • recent control fire
  • not as close as 1 to urban development

Referring to the table I see my data again falls within the range except for antimony. Cl is above the average

Sample 3
  • wooded area
  • recent control fire
  • near highway
  • note: water was vey cloudy

Antimony again is fairly high.

Sample 4
  • same as sample 3

Antimony again is high.

Sample 5
  • low shrubs
  • very close to landfill


The first data set falls within the range, but the second set has high antimony. Ba is relatively high for the average , but not uncommon.

Sample 6
  • low shrubs
  • very close to landfill
  • also near wetlands

Antimony is very high compared to the range.

Sample 7
  • same as sample 6


Data set one has high antimony levels, but set two has very high Ba readings.

Sample 8
  • same as sample 6

Antimony is high. Chlorine is as well above the range.

Sample 9
  • closest sample to landfill
Antimony is high compared to range.

Sample 10
  • in swamp area

Both data sets have high antimony levels. Set one has high bromine levels.

Sample 11
  • same as sample 10

Antimony levels are high compared to range.

Sample 12
  • near parking lot of Albany Pine Bush Center

Data set one has extremely high levels of bromine. Antimony levels are also high.

Conclusions

All eta sets had high levels of antimony meaning that it is probably an issue within the area. The moment we began sampling areas close to the landfill, bromine levels were very high. I might even add the antimony levels were relatively higher than areas that were mainly shrubs. In one sample the chlorine level was very high. The Albany Pine Bush center also had high bromine levels. This proves a point that urban development is not good for soil and actions should be taken to take care of the soil.




Monday, June 16, 2014

Comparing the X-Ray Analysis Default Test to the Extended Test

Comparing the X-Ray Analysis Default Test to the Extended Test 

INTRO
Samples collected from the Albany Pine Bush were first ran through the default analysis twice. After collecting the data, the samples were then ran again through the x-ray analysis, but this time an extended test was used. I did this in order to understand how much more precision is used in collecting data through an extended test as compared to a default test. Seeing as I am comparing the tests used and not the sample areas, I did not feel that I needed to look at all samples, so I only went through samples 1-7. Below are the samples and their data with the default and extended test.

Note: 2 data sets were collected for the default test

RESULTS

Sample 1
  • by shrubs
  • near houses
Default test




Extended test


Sample 2
  • by shrubs and woods
  • recent control fire
  • not as close as 1 to urban development
Default test




Extended test







Sample 3
  • wooded area
  • recent control fire
  • near highway
  • note: water was vey cloudy
Default test




Extended test


Sample 4
  • same as sample 3
Default test




Extended test



Sample 5
  • low shrubs
  • very close to landfill
Default test




Extended test


Sample 6
  • low shrubs
  • very close to landfill
  • also near wetlands
Default test




Extended test



Sample 7
  • same as sample 6
Default test




Extended test



Conclusions

What I found was rather interesting. It seemed that the majority of heavy metals compared between the default and extended test complimented each other. Because the default test is supposed to not be as precise as the extended test, I used the two data sets as a range for comparing the extended set's data to. As long as the extended test's data feel between the default data or very close on the outside, I counted it as being accurate. The first thing I will note is that most data points from the extended test had a small range of confidence, thus making them more precise. However, some extended points fell well out of the range, making me believe that the extensive test is not always the best. Below are several observations I made.
  • Sample 1: The different tests seemed to compliment each other well
  • Sample 2: The data matched well except for Pb
  • Sample 3: The tests did not seem to compliment each other
  • Sample 4: The different tests seemed to compliment each other well
  • Sample 5: All the data matched except for Ba
  • Sample 6: The tests did not seem to match well for Ba
  • Sample 7: Sb and Ba did not seem to match between the tests
I might chose to use the extended test over the default test, however I will run the test several times and use the mean for each elements count.